Genuine questions if you have the time to respond and if you can do so without pointing me in the direction of some other thread that would be much appreciated.
Did that mean if it hit 3302 on the offer, you'd hit the offer, or if it hit 3302 on the bid you'd hit the offer?
Does that mean having gone in at 3302 you'd need it to go above 3308 to stay in or 3310 to stay in? Which? And again, is that on the bid or the offer? And how long do you give it to go above 3308 or 3310 and how far will you let it come back before baliing out?
Again is this bid or offer you're using to trigger your scalp trades? And which of these levels is the trigger, 3300 or 3297?
So which is it 3, 5, 6 or 7 pips? And as you don't know until after the event whether the trade was a 5 pip scalp or a 25+ pip trade how do you utilise your method for establishing number of pips stop?
TIA for your response. Much appreciated.
Hi Sigma D
Sorry i did not have time enough to answer these questions in full during the main day - but now I have time etc
If I am scalp buying - it would be my ask price I am looking at - which of course might be 1-3 pips different to yours - as normally with different platforms and different brokers - you do get small differences in prices
The fact the most of the pairs I scalp have spreads under 1 pip - which I include in the stop as well - bid and ask might only be 0 3pip difference on my charts.
With scalp sells then its the lower bid price - but as you guess it could still be up to 2 or 3 pips different to what you are seeing even if at exact time with no lag - due to platform differences
Normally if I am scalping with another scalper on another platform - then we check to see what the differences are - so we can both work together on what we get on highs and lows.
This is one of the reasons I quote normally 2 prices within say 3 pips of each other - and so i might be happy to keep a scalp buy on over 3309 - but on other charts my 3309 is 3311 or even 3312.
Also if i quote 2 prices say 3- 7 pips apart - thats because sod's law say price will peak or stop in between - so by quoting both prices its clearer then on the decision making -ie we need above both to stay with a buy - or below both to stay with sell.
I really do try to keep all my trades with stops under 7 pips maximum and on 1 pip spreads or under - then 5 pips is my limit
I can normally see from the time and my LR structure if i can let it go 3-4 pips against me - and my stop is a soft stop as I enter and exit scalps on a one click basis and my proper stop only for emergencies is say 20 -25 pips away - ie normally large enough to deal with 4 -10 pip false spikes
For me every scalp trade is really unique - it just depends on so many factors - including time of session and day - and previous 5 -10 mins of PA.
So with the market being dynamic - I dont use fixed targets and really not fixed stops. If i can see a scalp which only need a 3 pip stop - thats my cut off - if i see a scalp needs 8 or 10 pips - i don't take it.
Similar i try not to be stopped out on full 5 pips on entries - if I enter and price goes 2 pips against me and does not go my way within under another minute - I will even exit at minus 2 or try for break even if it does not look as though the timing is right correct ,
Some days I can have 4 bad trades - and still not lost over 12 pips - I am that tight on only staying in the black
With regards to targets - yet again - I have ideas depending on how busy the market is and time of day - but if my target is 14 pips and it only gets to 9 pips and stops and drops then to 3 pips - i will exit if we dont make back above the 9 pips I had - i dont wait until it goes 3 or 5 pips against me
I have no fixed numbers of trades to take everyday - but reluctant to be in more than 3 scalps per hour and I can go some days an hour of two with no trade is price is really in a no trade zone
Flexibility is key to your money management - yes super tight stops but let your winners run - ideally leaving 30 -50% on with your stop in a few pips profit
You can then switch off micro managing your trade with no stress - you are in a win win situation - you will either get stopped out with just 1 or 3 pips or whatever - or the moves goes you way and 2 or 10 hrs later you collect 30 or 50 or even 100+ pips
Hope that helps for now - and I have no problem answering any queries etc on intraday FX trading - and can tell you - yes with practice - patience - and time - you can get there and then every 500 trades - you normally end up getting better
Regards
F