Ripcord..good HONEST posts by you. Thank you!! Like you, I have done it all (although I spent a long time on demos so never lost money) and I would say simple is best. I looked at one of my old charts the other days and I had EIGHT indicators!! I had, Aroon, TRIX, RSI, Stochs, ADX, BB's..the list was endless. Ididnt know what they meant, I didnt realise that some were confirming the same thing and I didnt know that some were only useful in oscillating non trending markets!!
I still think, picking a couple of MA and doing long above short below will yield a decent return with good money management and good entry and exit techniques.