Hi SD
No problem with your questions - you are welcome and i will try and explain in a bit more detail
My stake size is normally under 1% of the Capital account - as main account is around the $50 -70k level with profits withdrawn on a regular basis - and i base my 1% or less on approx 5 pips - not the hard stop at 20 -25 pip area.
The hard stop is hardly ever needed - its just a "safety valve" - I might go over 1000 trades and its never hit once - as I have either exited with profit or within 5 -7 pips manually.
With regards to a sudden spike - thats why I don't use a a hard stop at 5 -7 pips - you do get the occasional quick spike in under 1 second that might happen when you are up say 2 or 3 pips in profit and its say 6 or 9 pip move against you in a split second - and so an hard stop would be taken out - but in most cases- small spikes revert to normal during the next minute or so.
In 90% of all my scalps - price either goes in my favour - or goes away from me after entry and i would then try and exit under minus 3 pips if possible.
Its only the odd occasions you get the anomalies - so were you cover for them - you accept they might only happen now and again. Timing is critical on scalp entries - and when you enter - you want to be catching the start of the momentum and so if you have say just a 0 5 pip or 1 pip spread then after entry you accept 1 to 3 pips drawdown - but expect to be positive by 1 or 2 pips within 30 seconds or a few minutes
All my scalps are taken from a tick chart or a 1 minute - and i would expect them to all finish normally under 30 mins with many only taking 10 -15 minutes - so thats why I watch them . if I make over 15 or 25 pips great - I might exit with 100% and then look again in another time window. If PA is slow I might exit with 70% and then lock the 30% in with stop in profit - 1 or 2pips or even 5 pips if room and then just leave alone - and only watch every 10 mins or 30 mins and move my stop more into profit if I can.
Some 30% trades with stops in profits can remain in action for hrs or days and instead of just making say 10 -25 pips - you end up with 70 pips or 200+ pips .
My Best one for March was on the EA from 5500 - I still have that running with 500 pips of profit locked in still - although I have exited other EA sells since after it started to retrace back above 4800 and 4900.
Remember trading is not black or white - its mostly grey - you need to have rules - but they cannot be fixed in stone - they need to be dynamic and flexible - just like the market.
Hope that helps and will post a 1 min chart and also mention my current indicator settings
Hope that helps for a start
Regards
F
Thanks for your comprehensive response. I’m clearing the decks for tomorrow’s action and looking forward to following your blog comments.
Just so I understand your method:-
You place hard stop of 25 pips which rarely (once every 1000 trades) gets hit. Your soft stop of 3-7 pips will normally allow a spike of 15 pips and 20% of the time it isn’t a spike and ends up being a genuine reversal and you take between 13 and 25 pips loss.
70% of the time you enter and the price doesn’t move against you by more than 7 pips maximum. This in incredible performance! Almost unbelievable! I am so looking forward to following someone with this sort of performance tomorrow and this week that I can’t tell you how much I’m impressed.
More importantly, your position size is based on 5 pips – not 25, so when you win you base your win on a 5 pip (not 3-7) initial stoploss and when you lose, your lose is approximately 5 times your 1% risked (25 pips0. I wish I had the balls to risk 5% for 1%.
Really looking forward to this week.
For clarity, you’ll be stating which pair, an entry price and a clear indication of exit and all within the construct of the 15 pip, maybe 25, stoploss based on 1% per 5 pips position size.
This could be the week you silence all your critics. Clarify. Transparency and Total Openness.
I’ll be following you calls closely but obviously with a rather smaller position size.