Yamato
Legendary member
- Messages
- 9,840
- Likes
- 246
Replying as I read.
Oh, "a great job in holding himself back", that's good to know, so despite the fact you never wrote anything offensive, you're now defending someone who periodically insults my systems, without good reasons (if I say they're profitable, they're profitable - it's not like anyone has other knowledge about my systems that I do not have), and does so repeatedly, year after year. Oh, "frustrating experience"? Don't forget that you're not forced to read it.
Yeah, "you have the ability to be a successful discretionary trader and a successful systems trader and even both at the same time". I definitely don't mind any criticism given these premises you made. It's quite different from reading "million miles away" and "very disappointing".
Yeah, our emotions get in the way of money management.
"So sometimes you can really trust your emotions, and in other situations you shouldn't trust your emotions. The professional trader has to know which situation is which and go with his/her gut feelings when appropriate, and completely override them when appropriate.": interesting.
"Looking at a chart and just 'knowing' that it is going to bounce is an emotion.": in my case it is where my emotions should not be trusted, because any time i see a falling chart, I forecast a bounce. I don't wait for support to be reached, which is instead the case most of the time. The emotion involved in this case is my impatience and eagerness to trade.
"So is the desire to close a profitable trade to book the profit (good feeling) and the desire never to close a losing trade because of the bad feelings that come with booking a loss": very good description of other harmful emotions.
idea2develop
"Many people assume that this is too hard. However research shows that it can be done by anyone, unless your dorsolateral prefrontal cortex is damaged. ": ok, so I am not damaged in that part of my brain, but there can also be other reasons why I can't control the damage done by my emotions, such as learned environmental factors - personality... I don't remember what it's called. In other words, this might require so much work that I cannot easily fix this problem. Another thing I cannot seem to be able to fix is to stay away from trading if I am home, and it's too hard to stay outside all day long. This is all part of what we could describe as the "emotional problems of trading". Maybe.
Yes, I remember reading about the marshmallow test. The interesting thing is that I do not have addictions otherwise and I am very controlled otherwise (imagine being a vegan). It is as if I vented out in trading all my frustration for being so controlled in every other area of my life.
Oh, "By the way, you rarely post your trades anymore.": unless you're talking about just the last week, if you got this impression, it must be because you haven't read the last few months of posts, because in fact I post my trades much more than years ago, and I even went so far as posting a file where I analyze 16 markets and prepare for trades weeks in advance:
View attachment index.html
Yes, I'll be following the pope's election in the coming week(s).
Oh, "a great job in holding himself back", that's good to know, so despite the fact you never wrote anything offensive, you're now defending someone who periodically insults my systems, without good reasons (if I say they're profitable, they're profitable - it's not like anyone has other knowledge about my systems that I do not have), and does so repeatedly, year after year. Oh, "frustrating experience"? Don't forget that you're not forced to read it.
Yeah, "you have the ability to be a successful discretionary trader and a successful systems trader and even both at the same time". I definitely don't mind any criticism given these premises you made. It's quite different from reading "million miles away" and "very disappointing".
Yeah, our emotions get in the way of money management.
"So sometimes you can really trust your emotions, and in other situations you shouldn't trust your emotions. The professional trader has to know which situation is which and go with his/her gut feelings when appropriate, and completely override them when appropriate.": interesting.
"Looking at a chart and just 'knowing' that it is going to bounce is an emotion.": in my case it is where my emotions should not be trusted, because any time i see a falling chart, I forecast a bounce. I don't wait for support to be reached, which is instead the case most of the time. The emotion involved in this case is my impatience and eagerness to trade.
"So is the desire to close a profitable trade to book the profit (good feeling) and the desire never to close a losing trade because of the bad feelings that come with booking a loss": very good description of other harmful emotions.
idea2develop
"Many people assume that this is too hard. However research shows that it can be done by anyone, unless your dorsolateral prefrontal cortex is damaged. ": ok, so I am not damaged in that part of my brain, but there can also be other reasons why I can't control the damage done by my emotions, such as learned environmental factors - personality... I don't remember what it's called. In other words, this might require so much work that I cannot easily fix this problem. Another thing I cannot seem to be able to fix is to stay away from trading if I am home, and it's too hard to stay outside all day long. This is all part of what we could describe as the "emotional problems of trading". Maybe.
Yes, I remember reading about the marshmallow test. The interesting thing is that I do not have addictions otherwise and I am very controlled otherwise (imagine being a vegan). It is as if I vented out in trading all my frustration for being so controlled in every other area of my life.
Oh, "By the way, you rarely post your trades anymore.": unless you're talking about just the last week, if you got this impression, it must be because you haven't read the last few months of posts, because in fact I post my trades much more than years ago, and I even went so far as posting a file where I analyze 16 markets and prepare for trades weeks in advance:
View attachment index.html
Yes, I'll be following the pope's election in the coming week(s).