Yamato
Legendary member
- Messages
- 9,840
- Likes
- 246
good (but frustrating) movie
Here's another good (true, probably) story:
http://www.letmewatchthis.ch/watch-6083-My-Sisters-Keeper
This is art, not entertainment. It's painful to watch, but it tells a real story. Message vs entertainment.
The story is told pretty well, but the topic is so unpleasant that it's hard to watch it. Any director would have failed at making this a watchable movie. I mean I am watching it, but it's hard. That's you don't find that many movies about people dying from cancer.
[...]
Damn... life is sad enough without having to invent stories and yet this one seems to be invented:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Sister's_Keeper
On the other hand it could have happened. Anyway, this is the most depressing movie I have seen in years.
Oh, no wonder:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0426883/
Nick Cassavetes, same guy directing Alpha Dog, another movie telling the story of an announced death. Damn. Damn. This is awful. He directs movies with the opposite of hollywood happy ending.
Neither the sad ending nor the happy ending make any sense. The senseless ending is the one I'd want, like in Pierrot Le Fou:
Actually, I do not recommend this movie at all. Let's see how they rate it on rotten tomatoes:
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/10010662-my_sisters_keeper/
47%
I told you so.
This guy I agree with:
And this guy, too:
Here's another good (true, probably) story:
http://www.letmewatchthis.ch/watch-6083-My-Sisters-Keeper
This is art, not entertainment. It's painful to watch, but it tells a real story. Message vs entertainment.
The story is told pretty well, but the topic is so unpleasant that it's hard to watch it. Any director would have failed at making this a watchable movie. I mean I am watching it, but it's hard. That's you don't find that many movies about people dying from cancer.
[...]
Damn... life is sad enough without having to invent stories and yet this one seems to be invented:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Sister's_Keeper
On the other hand it could have happened. Anyway, this is the most depressing movie I have seen in years.
Oh, no wonder:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0426883/
Nick Cassavetes, same guy directing Alpha Dog, another movie telling the story of an announced death. Damn. Damn. This is awful. He directs movies with the opposite of hollywood happy ending.
Neither the sad ending nor the happy ending make any sense. The senseless ending is the one I'd want, like in Pierrot Le Fou:
Actually, I do not recommend this movie at all. Let's see how they rate it on rotten tomatoes:
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/10010662-my_sisters_keeper/
47%
I told you so.
This guy I agree with:
What starts as an exploration of the ethics of organ-donation and genetic selection, rapidly disintegrates into a sloppy, unstructured, tear-jerking mess.
July 30, 2009 Full Review | Comment (1)
Simon Weaving
Screenwize
And this guy, too:
The film has a profound and compelling premise. Regrettably, it seems intent on being about everything but that premise.
November 16, 2009 Full Review | Comment
Mike McGranaghan
Aisle Seat
Last edited: