Forgive the usual ramble folks...
I had a rewarding day today and would like to share it, not, I should stress (with a superfluous flurry of commas
), to inflate my ego in any way, but to expand on stuff a few of us were discussing in the chat room today.
Dunno if you've heard me say this before
but Forex price action has dazzled with its purity lately, in that it really does, generally, seem to obediently conform to the cliched instructions found on the typical TA tin. Being only sporadically, rather than continually, devious, it respects patterns, waves, Fibs etc. without trying to kick one out of position on every single point of technical significance. As you know, ES was superb at doing just that, at considerable cost to my account. Whether this is down to my failings, my personality (and, more importantly, failure to suppress it), the different characters of markets or a combination of the trio I do not know, but moving into Forex feels like I've stumbled out of the unpredicatable savagery of the Colosseum into a good natured round of Playstation with friends. Of course I want to win, but the pressure is slighter, the humour better, the aims of the other player more obvious and a modest but effective number of rules are known. Also the reactions surprisingly sharp for a Friday night
Right that's quite enough babbling - onto the price action
Euro futures 07:00-20:xxx GMT
Given my ongoing discipline problems I took a mechanical long entry at 1.2081 according to my variant of JonnyT's 1st hour breakout system, i.e waiting until the first 15 min bar closed above (or below - but not today) the first hour's range, with a standard 30 pip stop loss. Always pleasant to have an 'arbitrary' entry supported by other TA: there was a re-entry, by way of an almost marabozu candle (
), into a well established down channel after 7 long, clear waves down and a double bottom at 1.2050.
I added another long at 1.2092 in the consolidation (15 pt stop just below previous candle bottom). Perhaps this was a touch risky as I was buying just below a pivot point (yellow line) and I didn't wait for a higher high close. Then again entering in a consol pause in a trend is often better than waiting for the breakout as the stop can be tighter.
Sold this long swiftly at 1.2113 (38% retrace) as it approached next layer of resistance, a 9 day old trendline that probably deserved respect. I didn't like the look of the green 10:00 (inverse hammer?) candle that bounced down off this line either. Increasing volume and constant 10 EMA support could have kept me long but (sheepishly) 2 contracts are too hot for me to hold for long. The second contract was a 1:1.4 scalp essentially, bit silly, but I was happy adding given 1st contract profit.
Euro continued up, broke decisively into its old up channel, then above pivot R1,around which it formed a bull triangle. I was stopped out of my long at 1.2135 on the bull triangle bottom. I moved the stop there because the price bounced down off a 62% retrace and I was happy to let the market take me out, thus granted me perfect, unbiased calm to watch the triangle.
The triangle broke up as expected (arrogance unintentional) so I longed again at 1.2144 and closed this at 1.2175. There were a number of reasons for this, chiefly a need to urinate.
Also it was a 76.4% retrace after 5 messy waves up, at yesterday's high (not marked cause chart is not 24hr) and a quietly pessismistic inverse H&S target. Note the high volume bar that was accompanied in price by a a new spike high, but closed rather bearishly. Not a short signal by any means, but a warning. 3 bars later, bingo, chunky reversal after a double top on lower vol and a marginal new high on the reversal bar (as Skim has mentioned often I believe). Sorry this is becoming incoherent! Just gotta mention that 76.4% retrace level though - I ladmire it cause it takes out all the 62% Fibbers but allows for covert accumulation/distribution without competition from everyone looking to get in at 100%. Tis the unexpected level where reversals occasionally occur innit. Not...oh dear :|
Anyway at this point everyone reading this drivel nodded off, while any bubbles of pride I might be allowing to seep through were punctured by the realisation that I had disobeyed the system, exiting early instead of holding to the close as directed. But, in my defence, I felt I had compelling evidence to exit the long; the only task now was to re-establish it and thus satisfy the system.
Bearing in mind the Fed action, I placed a limit long just above the 9 day trendline at 1.2141 in the hope that a Fed spike would grab it. Stop 15 pips, in case the Fed rise was 0.5% and me Euro plunged, otherwise it wd have been 30 as usual. Damn system again, dictating arbitrary stops against one's supposedly better judgment.
Anyway the spike down was fulfilling and in the post Fed frenzy I crudely trailed the stop until it was hit at 1.2160.
Well, that's post event curve fitting for you! If I'm honest, just a very lucky day by all accounts, but at least perhaps I created a little of that luck by following the rules I have learnt and giving priorirty to those that bore most weight. Discretion was the better part of mechanics, or summat :cheesy: But what still confuses me is that I applied much the same ethic to ES, and she killed me.
:?: