Tw2,
First of all none of my comments are directed at you personally, or should be construed as critical of you as a person. I simply seek to elucidate the psychology of a variety of trading, investing methods, and as such, methodologies will often come under fire. So.......
Opinions, and technical analysis, must by definition, not exist.
As a technical trader, what price, and price direction "do" so must you, irrespective of what you think, feel, etc.
This is a stumbling block for many, as they take a "POSITION IN THEIR MINDS" when they place a position in the market, and have trouble, changing their MINDS when and if the market changes.
This is where fundamentally investors and traders part company. I will have an OPINION on an issue when I place a position in the market. Whether the market goes with me or against me is irrelevant, I am right, or wrong, not because the market says so, but because my analysis is either right or wrong.
Exactly so. And PRICE = SENTIMENT.
I have tried to get definitions from others in regard to a definition on price, and always get an observation of what price does, not what it is.
SENTIMENT can change in a heartbeat, be manipulated, led, and many other variables.
The Market, is a voting machine, invariably stupid, wrong, and prone to emotional outbursts, in other words totally irrational.
In TA, this is what you are attempting to trade. Therefore, to attach any credence to your analysis is foolhardy. My 4 variations of TA, might all be wrong today, stop me out, and reverse next week........who knows.
The point, is that whatever form of TA that you use, sentiment will shift against you at some point, invalidating your analysis, and causing you a loss. This is TA. You seek to make it profitable via money management techniques.
Absolutely not. What you see is sentiment, and sentiment changes.
What interests me is............
Does the amount of effort placed in the analysis, or the TIME TAKEN to LEARN a methodology, predispose the trader to believe in the analysis to a greater extent, than if it took him 10mins. to either implement or learn?
This after all is a thread in Psychology.
Cheers d998
First of all none of my comments are directed at you personally, or should be construed as critical of you as a person. I simply seek to elucidate the psychology of a variety of trading, investing methods, and as such, methodologies will often come under fire. So.......
Price did not say it would go below 15.00. I said that!
Opinions, and technical analysis, must by definition, not exist.
As a technical trader, what price, and price direction "do" so must you, irrespective of what you think, feel, etc.
This is a stumbling block for many, as they take a "POSITION IN THEIR MINDS" when they place a position in the market, and have trouble, changing their MINDS when and if the market changes.
This is where fundamentally investors and traders part company. I will have an OPINION on an issue when I place a position in the market. Whether the market goes with me or against me is irrelevant, I am right, or wrong, not because the market says so, but because my analysis is either right or wrong.
The tape is the tape. It tells it owns story. It would be quite foolish to say that price can't never change from bearish to bullish. Prices change all the time! We have to simply adjust.
Exactly so. And PRICE = SENTIMENT.
I have tried to get definitions from others in regard to a definition on price, and always get an observation of what price does, not what it is.
SENTIMENT can change in a heartbeat, be manipulated, led, and many other variables.
The Market, is a voting machine, invariably stupid, wrong, and prone to emotional outbursts, in other words totally irrational.
In TA, this is what you are attempting to trade. Therefore, to attach any credence to your analysis is foolhardy. My 4 variations of TA, might all be wrong today, stop me out, and reverse next week........who knows.
The point, is that whatever form of TA that you use, sentiment will shift against you at some point, invalidating your analysis, and causing you a loss. This is TA. You seek to make it profitable via money management techniques.
Today you seem to be making light of what I see in the tape. Are you?
Absolutely not. What you see is sentiment, and sentiment changes.
What interests me is............
You see, the more effort we put into our work, whatever that work may be, the greater our pride and sense of achievement in that work. Now, traders cannot afford this mindset..........they are either right or wrong..........if wrong they lose money even if it took them 6hrs to find and analyse this trade that took 30secs. to go against them..................the temptation, the slippery slope is to have pride in your work .....and give it time to prove you right.
Does the amount of effort placed in the analysis, or the TIME TAKEN to LEARN a methodology, predispose the trader to believe in the analysis to a greater extent, than if it took him 10mins. to either implement or learn?
This after all is a thread in Psychology.
Cheers d998