kriesau said:
Looking at that, I would add a few comments..
He says earnings consistently surprised on the upside, well if you look at the last two lots of estimates that was, ahem well, they lowered the estimates a lot, so the lowering earnings beat them, oh brilliant, earnings are falling, but they beat the estimates so that's alright then.
The p/e even showing a graph that looks like the p/e is dropping, Oil has not been factored into the future earnings, they haven't been able to pass on the costs and oil has gone up a lot more since past earnings.
That's a bit like saying inflation isn't going up cos the core isn't if you take out oil.. ahem, duh, you need oil.... it is a cost, duh....
Shall I go to my local petrol station and tell them I don't have to pay for it cos it doesn't count?
Also, a p/e of around 15 is not historically cheap by any means, oh of course you can distort this a lot if you add the dot bubble p/e into the average calculation! If earnings are decelerating then they ought to be cheaper than this.