FXCM dwarfs CMC, and they offer something very important, you will NEVER go in the red on your account by bad trading or bad luck. With many other SB companies including CMC, you can end up owing them ££££££££ as well as blowing your account balance. These are the facts, call them up, read their website. To me this is invaluable. CMC are not going to offer this to its clients which imho is a mistake because this is real client protection and a good selling point.
There was some lively debate going on in the CMC thread about FXCM’s no debit balance policy, and I thought I would go into more detail in FXCM’s own thread about our policy and our thoughts on this whole situation.
No Debit Balance Policy
One thing FXCM's traders can be confident with is that they will not lose more money than they deposit into their account. It is FXCM's policy to credit accounts to a zero balance when debit balances occur as a result of trading.
There are a couple of important points to emphasis with this:
1. We only offer the most liquid instruments in forex and CFD trading. This means that whenever you need to exit your positions because you've reached a margin call, there's a very high likelihood your positions can be closed without your account going into a debit balance. We don't offer any single share CFD's because of this. And for those currency pairs which are somewhat more exotic than the major pairs, such as the MXN, HUF, TRY, etc. a higher margin requirement is required as an additional buffer.
2. FXCM enforces a real margin requirement instead of waiting for your account to reach £0. The initial margin you are required to set aside when opening the trade is also the account liquidation level. If your account equity hits your margin requirement level, every trade in your account will automatically and immediately be closed to prevent your account from ending up in a debit balance.
It is possible in some instances during volatile markets that a gap could cause your account to end up in a small debit balance. It is FXCM's policy to credit accounts back to a zero balance when the debit balance occurs as a result of trading. One of the greatest concerns traders have about leverage is that a sizable loss could result in owing money to their broker.
With FXCM, you only risk what you put in.
The margin watcher in the FX Trading Station II platform makes it very easy for you to keep track of your margin. I have added some screenshots below of the FX Trading Station II show how the margin tracker and margin call on our platform works. In the accounts window, there is a column titled Usd Mr. That column keeps track of your current margin requirement for open positions. If your account equity drops to your Usd Mr level, a margin call will occur. All positions are closed immediately. In the below screenshot, account equity would need to drop to £50 for the margin call to occur. Account equity drops as losses on open positions increase.
In the next image, the Usd Mr (used margin) is larger since I have opened more positions thereby increasing my margin requirement. The margin requirement is now £500. If my account equity drops to £500, a margin call will occur and close all positions immediately. We do not let your account reach £0 before initiating the margin call.
Another nice feature in the accounts window is the color coding for the Usbl Mr column. Usbl Mr (usable margin) shows you how much margin you have leftover to sustain against further losses. (Equity = Usd Mr + Usbl Mr). You can also watch the Usbl Mr as an indication on whether you are in danger of a margin call. If your usable margin hits 0, then the margin call occurs. We color code the margin call as green, yellow, or red to give further notification you are in danger of a margin call. If your account margin drops to 30%, the column turns orange and a notification appears. If your account margin drops to 10%, the column turns red and a notification appears. See the screenshot below:
Margin Call: And of course, the dreaded margin call!!! A message will appear on your screen, and you will see all positions closing. I circled the close time in my positions window to show all positions were closed. Any leftover margin freed up as a result of the positions closing is placed back into my account which I can then use to open new positions.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
-Jason