Oliver,
I’m spread betting too. Stocks as well as currencies. Good trade on SPD, wish I had held on or even re-entered after getting spooked out, it would still have ended up a profitable trade most likely.
I’m trying to be a position trader, trading with the trend, buying on pullbacks if the trend is up and shorting on rallies if the trend is down. Pretty simple system just using trend lines and moving averages.
I find getting into the positions and setting the initial stops and target easy. The losers get stopped out automatically on most occasions and the winners start running. The problem is managing the winners! I want to ride the trend for as long as possible. But this becomes difficult the longer the trend goes on. Especially if the prices starts going vertical. You think it can’t go any higher as it’s so far away from the trend line. So you use your discretionary judgement and close the position…However the position keeps going and you miss all those points had you stuck to your original plan which was to let the winners run. Tis a difficult balance to achieve.
How are you going about setting stops once a position is well into a profit? You don’t really want to ratchet up the stop too much close to the current price in case you get stopped by rouge stop hunting spikes, but you don’t want it kept at the original stop either as you would end turning a winner into a loser. I feel some kind of rules would help, but I’m not entirely sure what would be good rules.
For example you closed out BDEV. However the trend is still up. It’s continuing up today. In fact it’s a lovely uptrend, with a clear lower trend line and an upper trend line. Yet you used discretion to close out the trade. The trend may continue for some time yet, but you’ll now miss any further upside. Now you have to do the hard work again and look for another entry or another stock completely. You said yourself it hasn’t come close to your target, so really you should probably still be in this trade, with some kind of stop loss strategy to stop you loosing what you have already made. Now if you find any good stop loss strategy please let me know because that’s the problem I’m currently having on winning positons!