Just thought i'd chime in here.
it's been around six months since I started this journal, and I have been creamed by the market averages. The purpose here is not to demonstrate a profitable approach but instead to give myself some simulated experience, a sample population of trades to reflect on come year end.
I am not a profitable trader but merely sticking with this approach, refining it until I see consistent gains and then slowly funding an account 🙂 . But still some time left - 6 months until the 'trading year' ends for me .
It takes a lot of time to become competent at a single approach in trading. It definitely requires a feedback loop of trial and error. Trading weekly charts is a very slow feedback cycle: a scalper has 20 trades a day, I would have 20 trades a year, etc. So , grinding through this chopping up and down, win some lose some, is vitally important for me imo.