isa's short term trading journal

My analysis of the price action from Friday was wrong. Although it looked bearish to me, the S&P 500 clearly wanted to go higher today for whatever reason, so I was stopped out of my position for a 0.49% loss to the account or -1.31% ATR(200) adjusted loss. I'm annoyed with myself for my lack of discipline to put on this trade when I was supposed to be on a stop until the end of the month. I need to chill out for a bit, as I've clearly not got a good read on the price action at the moment.
 
I know the feeling isa! Been there, seen it, done it!

But, don't be too hard on yourself. At least you've identified the problem. Now you just need to concentrate on avoiding it in future.
 
Thanks, is appreciated.

I think I'm going to do a full review over the next few weeks or so as it's been almost 6 months since I started this journal now. So is a good point for a bit of reflection. The account is in an ok position as I'm only down 3.13% since I started it, so is not too much to worry about. I think I might try to focus a bit more on a single method as I'm flip flopping around trying different stuff, which has been useful, but I think short term swing trading is my favourite method, so I'm going to concentrate on that and use the one trade a week ATR method I've been working on in the other thread to try and get some consistency.
 
new trade:

DAX SHORT, £3/PT @ 6817. Stop: 6834, target: initial; 6780, secondary; 6730

Seems stuck at this level. OR its consolidating!!

[edit] stop to b/e (10.40am)

sweet!

[edit] stop to b/e+10 (10.58am)

[edit] stop to b/e+20 (6797) (11.01am)

[edit] out at 6797 for +20pts (+£60) (11.15am)
 
Last edited:
Seeking consistency

My trading break over the last few weeks has been useful and has given me a chance to do some more reading and analyse where my problems are. I identified some key areas where I am falling down and hence need to rectify. They are:

1. Position sizing: I have been really inconsistent with this, but I've now got a method for calculating what the position size should be based on average true range from my work in my competition thread on this.

2. Over trading: I have found that swing trading suits my style the best and so I'm going to cut down the amount of trades I make per week as I need to be able to put the appropriate amount of time into the research before putting on a trade and also have enough time to monitor the position during the week.

3. Targets: Although my target method mentioned in the opening post is sound for longer swing trades I've found that I particularly like a max trade length of a week and so I've developed a new target method based again on average true range where I look at the 200 day ATR and the 52 Week ATR. This is still a work in progress, but I've found a target range between 1 and 2 x the daily ATR is very achievable each week, and so I will be aiming for this from now on and aiming for a higher win/loss ratio as well.

4. Relative Strength: This has become a key principle for me lately and I've been doing a lot of reading on the subject. There is some great work on this in Point & Figure Charting by Dorsey and I'm using the techniques to analyse stocks relative to their sector and the market before I even consider trading them. It's a really detailed subject, but I think it's going to become key to my trading method as well as average true range.

Another change I have made is that I withdrew around 77% (£3000) of my money from the spread betting account and have placed it in my ISA. The reason for this is that I keep my position sizes below 0.5% of my account and have a max draw down per month of 3%. So the majority of my money is just sitting idol making the spread betting firm interest and is at risk if a black swan event happens. So I thought about it and realised that I could mitigate my black swan risk and make some interest on my trading fund by moving three quarters of it to my ISA and investing it in very slow moving cash bonds and gilts etc. I haven't decided which yet, but I should be able to make 3-6% a year interest in these low risk funds and the money would be available to withdraw if I ever blew up the remaining 23% spread betting account. The spread betting firm also has an 80% margin limit where they close the position automatically if it breaches this level, so that will be in-effect my disaster stop if the product gaps through my stop loss. It's very unlikely though that I will ever get near this as my position sizes will still be very small, though proportionally bigger because of the smaller account size at around 2% per trade. I will also only have one position open at a time so my risk should stay relatively small.

Anyway, I start again on Monday and will be trading my one trade a week method. Results from my other thread have been fairly good so far so lets see if I can continue this and make this into a consistent trading method.

Cheers
 
FXPO.L Update

FXPO.L was just too strong for me to get into today. I was waiting for a small pullback in the morning to around the S1 pivot level at roughly 437 but it just kept going up and finished the day up 4.9% in the end. So I think it's got a good chance of challenging the old high of 484.5 this week now as today's move had good volume as well to back it up. So I'm going to try and get in around the 456.5 support1 level if it pulls back a bit tomorrow.
 

Attachments

  • FXPO_Daily_PnF_4-4-11.png
    FXPO_Daily_PnF_4-4-11.png
    15.3 KB · Views: 172
  • FXPO_Daily_4-4-11.png
    FXPO_Daily_4-4-11.png
    164.9 KB · Views: 168
FXPO.L Entry

FXPO.L was just too strong for me to get into today. I was waiting for a small pullback in the morning to around the S1 pivot level at roughly 437 but it just kept going up and finished the day up 4.9% in the end. So I think it's got a good chance of challenging the old high of 484.5 this week now as today's move had good volume as well to back it up. So I'm going to try and get in around the 456.5 support1 level if it pulls back a bit tomorrow.

Trade

Ferrexpo Rolling Spread
Direction: Long

Entry Price: 460.12
Spread: 2.59 pts (ATR adjusted spread: 0.18%)

Stop loss: 446.9
Target: 484.5 (2/3rds off order)

ATR Adjusted Risk: -0.98%
ATR Adjusted Reward: 1.61%

Risk Ratio: 1.64

ATR (200 Day): 14.51 (3.15%)
ATR (52 Week): 38.34 (8.31%)

ATR Targets:
-1.1x ATR: 475.63
1x ATR: 475.63
1.5x ATR: 482.89
2x ATR: 490.14

Entry
I got in this one a bit early at 13.50pm as it looked like it was holding the 460 level. But I was too early and it broke down just after I entered to reach my original target. So I need to exercise more patience.
 

Attachments

  • SharpChartv05.png
    SharpChartv05.png
    26.2 KB · Views: 186
  • FXPO_15min_5-4-11.png
    FXPO_15min_5-4-11.png
    9.7 KB · Views: 178
FXPO.L Update

FXPO.L bounced off the 456 daily support level and made a strong finish to the day. So currently am 0.39% ATR adjusted in profit. My plan is to take of 2/3rds of the risk at 484.5 and let the remaining run with a trailing stop at the 30min -1ATR level. Lets see if it can go to plan.
 

Attachments

  • FXPO_15min_EOD_5-4-11.png
    FXPO_15min_EOD_5-4-11.png
    10.6 KB · Views: 170
  • SharpChartv05-1.png
    SharpChartv05-1.png
    26.2 KB · Views: 174
  • SharpChartv05-2.png
    SharpChartv05-2.png
    28.4 KB · Views: 182
Last edited:
FXPO.L Update

FXPO.L had a good open this morning. The initial target of 484.5 looks possible today, so we'll see how it plays out.
 

Attachments

  • FXPO_Daily1_PnF_6-4-11.png
    FXPO_Daily1_PnF_6-4-11.png
    14.1 KB · Views: 165
FXPO.L Update

FXPO.L reached my 1ATR level which is also the daily R2 pivot level so I took 2/3rds profits at 474.45 and will let the remaining 1/3rd play out. But this is now a free trade with a locked in 0.56% ATR adjusted gain.

Attached is the 30 min chart
 

Attachments

  • FXPO_30min_23off_6-4-11.png
    FXPO_30min_23off_6-4-11.png
    12 KB · Views: 181
FXPO.L Update

I'm going to keep my stop loss below the daily support level of 456 for now, as although on the daily chart there is still 4 to 6% relative to the 200 day moving average to go before it is as high as at was in January. The weekly price is at relative resistance now of 38% above the 200 day moving average and price is also approaching the all time high at 484.50 and is within a days range of that, so I want to give my remaining 1/3rd position a bit of room as the old high should provide some resistance. If it breaks out then my aim to trail a stop roughly around the -2ATR intra-day level on the 60 minute chart and see how much it's willing to give me.
 

Attachments

  • FXPO_Daily2_PnF_6-4-11.png
    FXPO_Daily2_PnF_6-4-11.png
    14.2 KB · Views: 174
  • FXPO_Daily_6-4-11.png
    FXPO_Daily_6-4-11.png
    164 KB · Views: 166
FXPO.L Update

FXPO.L made a new breakout this morning and almost reached the daily 1 ATR level but it has pulled back a bit during the morning back into a column of Os again on the intra-day charts, so it could be a bull trap. So I'm tightening my stop loss to break even at the 460 level to protect my profits on this one.

Attached is the charts
 

Attachments

  • FXPO_30min_PnF_8-4-11.png
    FXPO_30min_PnF_8-4-11.png
    15.9 KB · Views: 165
  • SharpChartv05-13.png
    SharpChartv05-13.png
    26.1 KB · Views: 164
FXPO.L Update

A positive day for FXPO.L but it showed some weakness at the back end of the day and is close to reversing back into a column of Os after making a triple top breakout today on the daily chart.

ATR(200) is 14.59 so my stop at 460.3 is just at the end of one days range and Mondays R3 pivot level is at 461.87 so my stop is just below that as well. So I'll leave it be until Mondays open is out of the way.

My stop loss is above the the major support level so there is a chance of being whipsawed out of the remaining 1/3rd position, but I'm looking to move it up to where the sell signal is on the 30min chart if it opens higher on Monday to lock in 10 points of profit.

Here are the charts
 

Attachments

  • FXPO_30min_PnF_8-4-11.png
    FXPO_30min_PnF_8-4-11.png
    16.4 KB · Views: 153
  • FXPO_Daily_PnF_8-4-11.png
    FXPO_Daily_PnF_8-4-11.png
    14.6 KB · Views: 156
Last edited:
HOC.L - Hochschild Mining entry

Ticker: HOC.L
Direction: Long

Entry: 625.74
Spread: 3.99 (0.18% ATR Adjusted)

Stop loss: 599
Target: 680

Percentage Risk: -4.27% (-1.23% ATR Adjusted)
Potential Reward: 8.72% (2.50% ATR Adjusted)

Risk Ratio: 2.04

ATR (200 Day): 21.82 (3.49%)
ATR (52 Week): 47.2 (7.54%)

ATR Targets:
-1x ATR: 603.92
1x ATR: 647.56
1.5x ATR: 658.47
2x ATR: 669.38
 

Attachments

  • HOC_entry_15min_11-4-11.png
    HOC_entry_15min_11-4-11.png
    17.4 KB · Views: 189
HOIL.L - Entry

Limit order at 284.5 was filled for Heritage Oil.

Ticker: HOIL.L
Direction: Long

Entry: 284.5
Spread: 1.23 (0.09% ATR Adjusted)

Stop loss: 273
Target: 320.6

Percentage Risk: -4.04% (-0.80% ATR Adjusted)
Potential Reward: 12.69% (2.50% ATR Adjusted)

Risk Ratio: 3.14

ATR (200 Day): 14.44 (5.08%)
ATR (52 Week): 37.66 (13.24%)

ATR Targets:
-1x ATR: 270.06
1x ATR: 298.94
1.5x ATR: 306.16
2x ATR: 313.38

Here is the 30 min chart
 

Attachments

  • Picture 6.png
    Picture 6.png
    48.3 KB · Views: 182
  • SharpChartv05-1.png
    SharpChartv05-1.png
    26.8 KB · Views: 160
Last edited:
HOC.L - Hochschild Mining exit

Ticker: HOC.L
Direction: Long

Entry: 625.74
Spread: 3.99 (0.18% ATR Adjusted)

Stop loss: 599
Target: 680

Percentage Risk: -4.27% (-1.23% ATR Adjusted)
Potential Reward: 8.72% (2.50% ATR Adjusted)

Risk Ratio: 2.04

ATR (200 Day): 21.82 (3.49%)
ATR (52 Week): 47.2 (7.54%)

ATR Targets:
-1x ATR: 603.92
1x ATR: 647.56
1.5x ATR: 658.47
2x ATR: 669.38

I've taken profits at the Daily 1 ATR level which is just above the R1 pivot level also. Here's the closing trade details:

Closing Trade

HOC.L (Hochschild Mining)
Direction: Long

Entry: 625.74
Exit: 640.22

Percentage Gain: 2.31%

ATR Adjusted Percentage Gain: 0.66%

Trade Grade: C

Edit: I added the full days chart from the actual price feed to show the whole marked up trade. Am pleased with this one.
 

Attachments

  • Picture 8.png
    Picture 8.png
    46.3 KB · Views: 185
  • HOC_trade_11-4-11.png
    HOC_trade_11-4-11.png
    11 KB · Views: 178
Last edited:
HOIL.L - Exit

Limit order at 284.5 was filled for Heritage Oil.

Ticker: HOIL.L
Direction: Long

Entry: 284.5
Spread: 1.23 (0.09% ATR Adjusted)

Stop loss: 273
Target: 320.6

Percentage Risk: -4.04% (-0.80% ATR Adjusted)
Potential Reward: 12.69% (2.50% ATR Adjusted)

Risk Ratio: 3.14

ATR (200 Day): 14.44 (5.08%)
ATR (52 Week): 37.66 (13.24%)

ATR Targets:
-1x ATR: 270.06
1x ATR: 298.94
1.5x ATR: 306.16
2x ATR: 313.38

Here is the 30 min chart

I was too early on HOIL.L and my stop loss was hit at 273 yesterday. It was dragged down with the rest of the market and I was whipsawed out, but I think it'll be a interesting one to watch in the next week or so as it's close to a major support level from the last few years which it reacted strongly off of in early March. So I'll be watching to see if it can base around the 260 level.

Here's the closing trade details:

Closing Trade

HOIL.L (Heritage Oil)
Direction: Long

Entry: 284.5
Exit: 273.00

Percentage loss: -4.04%

ATR Adjusted Percentage loss: -0.71%

Trade Grade: E

So it wasn't the trade I hoped for from the squeeze setup, but the stop loss did it's job. So on to the next one.

Below is the marked up charts
 

Attachments

  • HOIL_Daily_13-4-11.png
    HOIL_Daily_13-4-11.png
    16.8 KB · Views: 181
  • HOIL_30min_exit_13-4-11.png
    HOIL_30min_exit_13-4-11.png
    15.9 KB · Views: 177
HOC.L - Hochschild Mining Intra-day trade

I've tried a few times with Hochschild Mining this week and had a win on Monday and loses on Tuesday and Wednesday and a win again today. I've been testing an intra-day entry method that I like which I normally use for daily entries, but I thought it could work on a 30 minute time frame as well. It's a simple method using two candles for confirmation of the direction change that I found on the Britishbulls website. Anyway, here's the details of this mornings quick HOC.L trade.

Closing Trade

HOC.L (Hochschild Mining)
Direction: Long

Entry: 580.15
Exit: 586.32

Percentage Gain: 1.06%

ATR Adjusted Percentage Gain: 0.28% (0.46% inc spread)

Trade Grade: C-

Exit Reason
My target was the Daily 1x ATR level which was close to the R2 pivot, but I thought the combination of the 50 bar EMA and R1 pivot would pose some strong resistance after 3 down days for HOC.L so I chose to bank profits there.

This will probably be my last intra-day trade on HOC.L as the spread is too wide for scalping, so I need to find more liquid stocks to trade intra-day.

Below are the charts of the trade.

[EDIT]: I've added the full days marked up chart. My original target at the daily 1ATR level was reached and it closed fairly strongly above it. So that looks like a short term trend change for HOC.L IMO, as yesterdays long tail and today's strong reversal off of the long term trend line seems to indicate a sentiment change. So that makes it a buy-if candidate for me now on a daily time frame. So to confirm that I'd want to see it open higher and close higher again on Monday and then I'll look for an new entry point on Tuesday if it does.
 

Attachments

  • HOIL_30min_entry_15-4-11.png
    HOIL_30min_entry_15-4-11.png
    10.7 KB · Views: 173
  • HOIL_30min_exit_15-4-11.png
    HOIL_30min_exit_15-4-11.png
    11.1 KB · Views: 178
  • HOC_30min_trade_15-4-11.png
    HOC_30min_trade_15-4-11.png
    12.7 KB · Views: 183
  • SharpChartv05.png
    SharpChartv05.png
    24.9 KB · Views: 171
Last edited:
Top