I'll be also the one that says you should stay.
By the way for those who don't want to read his replays, and this thread - don't read it...
Even if I don't understand always what TE says (maybe because of my English, or because of his methods...) I’m not saying that i know everything, and everyone is stupid, I’m always open to new methods to add to my trading arsenal, to improve my trading.
Even if we assume that TE is only here to talk and show how smart he is, and he is not trading or trading profitable, that doesn't mean that some of his ideas can't be used by others to make money, to improve their trading
Look for example at teachers, professors at universities (maybe in English speaking countries situation is different, I don't know, or maybe I has such experience) - when someone teaches you for example management or marketing - that doesn't mean he makes from it money... But does that mean that this knowledge can't be used in practice profitable? When I was a student a few times I asked my professor to advice me with some problems in practice concerning what he was teaching, guess what - he couldn't!! Because all his knowledge was from books, not from practice.
Have a great day to all
Alex
Yes, good point TL.
... I would be delighted if someone can prove me wrong and quote great trading insights and pearls of wisdom that will be of benefit to current and future subscribers to the thread. In which case, not only can it stay where it is, I'll consider including it in the forum's 'Best Threads' Sticky. Can't say fairer than that can I!
Tim.
Yes, good point TL.
I've had it in the back of my mind for a while now to move the thread to the The Foyer in the 'Lounge' category which goes some way towards addressing the problem. If TE or his disciples can put forward a sound argument for leaving it where it is - i.e. by providing some evidence - any evidence in fact - that it makes a genuine effort to deliver on the promise implied in the title - then fair enough - it can stay put. As it is, it's clearly not about trading anymore and, as far as I can tell, never really was. But perhaps that's because I'm too stupid or unwilling to help myself to see what's really in it. If that's the case, I can console myself that I'm not the only one! I know DT and (I think) Charlton say they've been exploring new avenues as a result of reading TE's posts, but it strikes me that any progress they may be making is a consequence of their own efforts and can't be attributed to anything specific that TE has posted. On that basis, someone could, in theory, develop their trading skills having read a post in the 'Joke of the Day' thread. Having said all that, I would be delighted if someone can prove me wrong and quote great trading insights and pearls of wisdom that will be of benefit to current and future subscribers to the thread. In which case, not only can it stay where it is, I'll consider including it in the forum's 'Best Threads' Sticky. Can't say fairer than that can I!
Tim.
