patricio_w
Member
- Messages
- 86
- Likes
- 1
G-Man said:Patricio,
What is your opinion about the retracement of wave 4 into the range of wave 1. Strict Elliott rules say wave 4 cannot go below, in the current up move, the top of wave 1, but we have now exceeded this by quite some way in the current pattern.
Do you subscribe to this rule or are you in the 'should not' camp rather than the 'must not'?
Thanks,
G-Man
Gman,
This is not the case of overlaping range W4 into W1, because are different subdivision, theory says than W4 should not enter into range of W1 of the same range, i mean on the same division. W4 of small range can enter on range of W1 of bigger range.
But, lets supouse than this is the case of overlaping Waves, where says than W4, or W1 or whatever??. Elliot Wave Analysis has nothing to be with Forex or Rules. All of this theiorys and cases of WC,d,e,X adn that "rules" we are mencioning are depending of the analist. You will fine thousands of many differents interpretation about EW Theory. EW mencioned 5 Waves and 3 Waves patron, all that came after are interpretations. Me??, i personally think that if W4 enters into W1 range of the same range, i ll take a deep better look, because maybe my analysis is wrong, but i will not "kill" a hold good analysis just for that. The same happens with Wave s B flat, and Wave 2 than cross the extreme of Wave 1, and Wave 5 s than runs much longer of the possible targets. In EW analysis evcerything, i mean everything is possible, u have to insert your knowledge and theory to understand the trend of the market, then if it is Wave 1 or % or C it doesnt matter, for me its important to understand the correct trend, to follow the direction of the market
Of course its only my point of view, i read others, an of course iam open mined to learn every day
Kindest Regards