des,
Nice gear change and one that deserves it's own thread IMO. I think many more members than the relative few attracted to this particular thread would be interested in your idea. If you decide to go down this route, may I suggest the following, - posters should state where they are on their trading journey and which book was most valuable to them at what stage of their journey. For instance, Naz (Alan Rich) might include an advanced book on level II in his selection of three, but it wouldn't be appropriate for a newbie to rush out and buy it. Additionally, you might like to have a core selection which it is assumed every trader has read to ensure the same titles don't get repeated ad infinitum, e.g. Reminiscences of a Stock Operator, Technical Analysis of Stock Trends etc. A bit like The Bible and the complete works of Shakespeare on desert island discs. In this way, the thread will be more interesting to read and potentially more revealing.
Tim.