DionysusToast
Legendary member
- Messages
- 5,965
- Likes
- 1,501
I'm at odds with you here DT.
As far as I can tell, the approach that TRAW takes is keeping track of stock fundamentals and looking for trading opportunities when the fundamentals change. This, as a non-stock trader, makes perfect sense: Look for where the flow will be and front run / fade it as apppropriate using DOM/T&S as a cue.
Actually - that's what Mr C does. What TR does is multiple positions using L1 info.
With DOM/T&S - you mostly look at a single stock to enter at any one time BUT you get a more refined entry, which TR claims is impossible. He specifcally says that you can't use L2/DOM to get a good entry - so you just have to get in and manage it by scaling up & down. It is true that with TRs method you don't have to have a specific directional opinion. Mind you - neither does Mr C.
With L1 - you get a less refined entry and so the method is to get in to a stock that will move. You scale in when it does your way and scale out when it doesn't.
You can see on the video how it pans out..
If we look at 6:43 - we can see 46,600 shares traded.
ABM short 1000 - Profit $20.50
SCHL short 200 - Profit -$27
GIS Long 3400 - Profit -$88
ATU Short 2800 - Profit -$48.13
Close P&L - $396
At this point value of positions is $228,804
Now - as the day goes on - if trades go against, there's scaling out. If trades go your way you scale in.
So - nothing wrong so far but it is clear that the method is more of a scattergun approach - you don't try to predict direction, you try to follow it and trade enough stocks so you get a runner to make up for the losses. TR also says any other method of day trading stocks will not work.
Fast forward to 7:07 and we have over 53,000 shares traded and we stand at.
ABM - short 1200 - 25.07 - P&L $9.40
GIS - Long 7000 - 36.46 - P&L $935.22
ATU - Short 1200 - 26.57 - P&L -$111
At this point closed P&L is -$416 and open P&L is $786.
Margin is now $317k. There's $250K riding on the 7000 share position.
Now - TR makes a profit on the day of $600 and a total of 62,400 shares traded. From the videos I have seen the pattern is similar. Building up bigger and bigger positions of the runners as the day progresses. I haven't seen a video where the market goes against aggressively and I don't know what safeguards are in place to protect against this.
So - we get in with a small amount of contracts, scale up as it goes our way, scale out if it goes against - keep doing this all day and based on the stocks selected, you stand to benefit from the runners.
Now - is this the only way to trade ? Of course not. Is it risky ? You decide.
Using less information - i.e. just L1 info means you have to get into more positions and manage them aggressively. Using more information (L2 /T&S) means you can get into less positions at the right time. This is as you'd expect.
Both methods are equally valid but will suit different people depending on their account size and attitude to risk.
Last edited: