Pat - would you rule out directional trading on longer timeframes (H4 upwards) as being unprofitable on a longer term basis if it isn't discretionary (I'm thinking of people who use TA here)?
I’m walkin inta a minefield whichever way I answer. I don’t personally know that many traders who have or do trade on a purely directional basis. So me direct experiential evidence of their success is based on a sample so small as to be statistically irrelevant. But if I add in the consensus (anywhere between 90-98% walking away with less than they started with) me view is that regardless of timeframe, it’s a hiding to nothing.
Now of course, by random chance there are goin to be a small, small, small number who by whatever methods or means – including pure luck – have managed to turn a steady profit and are still playing the game years later. But if I were heading off inta the game on that basis, I’d be wonderin whether I was part of the 2% or the 98% and probably imagining the former rather than the more likely latter.
This isn’t a value judgement on those that do, but for me if I take a net directional play, which I have done, it’s a punt, but I know it’s a punt and not a trade. If I’m not hedging net exposure it’s a punt pure and simple. Me main business is not taking punts, but assessing an edge on a given set of conditions and when and only when I can see me way clear to locking in an immediate, typically no to occasionally low risk profit, then I’ll structure a trade which expresses me views. And I’ll stay with that trade until such time I’m proved wrong or it no longer does. And while it does, I’ll tinker away keeping it in trim with the changing vectors of global commerce. (That last bit was feckin poetry, pure en simple).
A simple example. If I know a man who has orange juice to sell at 110 and someone else I know is willing to buy at 140 then I will transact a trade. If I know people are willing to buy/sell at 140 today but I think the price will go lower based on technical and current fundamentals (both of which would be currently valid positions to take) and I sell short in the hope and expectation I can cover at a lower price later on, that would be a punt.