I know who you are, I know the person and he isn't on the order flow forum, I won't expose you though.
We're not all idiots btw (at least I hope I'm not one).
The thing is he does put forward some very interesting trade concepts/ideas that do seem to pan out in the main part (so far). Add to that the amount of time he spends helping people is it any wonder everyone is hot for it? Yes a good ROI if it is a scam but where else will the members go for a mentor that is so accessible.
I must admit to my heart progressively sinking when the BP forum thread started linking to the twitter (one step removal), then more when the twitter started linking to the forum (isolation from forum 'protection'), then (not entirely unexpectedly) live room with joining fee got announced.
Not so much for the fee but for the potential wasted time which is imo much more valuable.
But then there is a dearth of verified mentors/tutors. Name one that is openly held accountable as winning via myfxbook or anything similar?
In other industries people don't just say they can do it, they prove it. Forex seems to be the self certifying exception to the rule. Maybe those truly successful are too busy enjoying life with their riches. Maybe the profitable trader is a myth. I'm starting to wonder.
It's little wonder people fall for the scams so much.
Hi jgaret
According to information I read - less than 5% of forex traders can make money on a continual basis day in and day out and maintain it for months and years.
I am fortunate to be one of these traders. I have been retail forex trading for over 10 yrs with 6 yrs full time - and its only been in the last 3 years that I have become very consistent and can generally exceed my 50 pips target most days - and even on really bad days when I might have 4+ bad trades - I still end up profitable - but just have to work a longer session and take then probably 15+ intraday trades.
To achieve my consistency - I have easily now done over 10k hours of live small frame chart watching and calculated I have executed now over 12k live trades with well over 7000 being scalp trades. (includes thousands and thousands of losses as well ;-(
So to answer your question - it can be done - but takes a lot of time, loads of dedication and commitment - the ability to be focused and control your emotions and of course enough money to live on - until you get there. And when you get there unless you understand advanced MM - you will not stay there ;-)
If it is only 5% or less who reach these levels ( probably 20-30% can trade and make money but are just not consistent enough and having losing months etc) then you can totally understand all the scam artists and fraudsters in this game and they just fail to inform all their followers that if they were in the "5% special traders" brigade - they would not be spending so much time on twitter and websites marketing all what they do - and that their main income - ie 70% + would be coming from trading.
I personally don't sell courses. books, tutorials or anything connected with forex trading - but will admit I am not able to make multi millions every year from my own account simply because I hit my own personal psychological money wall at trading approx 22 lots per pip. I could not hack it above that level and feel more comfortable with less than £100 per pip.- especially with my own money.
I have improved since then but being in my late 50's have not intention of putting myself through it again - and so stay with my own stake levels - that certainly can provide a very comfortable living.
To become a lawyer - or a surgeon or other highly rewarded professional - it takes 5 -7 yrs before you start seeing the real rewards.
Why would any new trader not realise it will take the same time or even longer to achieve it in retail Forex trading ?
Regards
Forexmospherian