As I'm reading through these good comments, I keep coming back to the question of "whipsaw". Using the MACD histograms, I have seen the whipsaw impact at first hand - not too often certainly, but often enough to be blown out of enough trades. Clearly the MACDs are momentum indicators and are laggers. So, what do I use to get a better feel for "solid" momentum as opposed to momentum susceptible to whipsaw....? For example are the Stochastic lines more ahead of the curve so to speak...?
If on the other hand, there are no "crystal ball" signals, then does it solely rely on the percentage game i.e. as long as one has the signals near-enough correct (e.g. a colour cross-over) then take the trade, but expect some to whipsaw and some to work out OK. The more of the latter raises the trader's overall performance but one has to "hope" that the gainers outdo the losers overall.......is that about it..............?
If on the other hand, there are no "crystal ball" signals, then does it solely rely on the percentage game i.e. as long as one has the signals near-enough correct (e.g. a colour cross-over) then take the trade, but expect some to whipsaw and some to work out OK. The more of the latter raises the trader's overall performance but one has to "hope" that the gainers outdo the losers overall.......is that about it..............?