I have found in the past that being too finicky about exact entry prices meant that alot of good trades blasted off for the stars with me left standing at Cape Canaveral rueing the fact that I had been a dick for a tick!
this is so true Dr L, u obviously speak from experience & r not just a fancy talker as I first thought..........I apologise.
I think this is one of those debates that will have no winner......would be a bit like trying to convince a 'black belt' that a punch on the nose & swift kick in the nuts would be just as affective.....you'll just end up scrapping.
In what I have learned I would say both r important, but it all comes down to how u personally trade at the end of the day. for if somebody is successful....they r successful & just because somebody disagrees it wont make that system fail.
one point I will make is that when I first began trading I never second guessed myself, managed the trade well & had good consistent success............when I started to 'analyze' & compare to what others were doing & try to make it an exact science............my confidence fell, I failed to execute trades, always second guessed & took early profits & my profits fell. this has taken a long, long time to get over
my point: entry & exit r important, as they r part of trading, but a belief in what U r doing is I think more so
Jay