myattitude
Established member
- Messages
- 533
- Likes
- 70
Reply with your answer. Let's count up the votes, which one(s) is a live call to you:
1) "l 10233, sl 15" "out +20"
2) "im long"
3) (5 minutes after a move happened) "scalps taken from res. nailed it."
???
I appreciate some people never explicitly said they are making their threads to place live calls and are under no obligation, but some people pretend to be making live calls.
Hi I'm Troy Mclure, you might remember me from this thread that I made for transparency, that I haven't updated for months now since starting up my new business enterprise. That thread was about as open as live calls could ever be and yes, I showed my losses (I was a noob trader, still am).
I've recently come back to this forum and dipped back in to a bit of trading the past 2 weeks but I see there is still a lot of smoke and mirrors on T2W.
What I don't understand is why waste your own time let alone everybody elses? If you're not making live calls properly, shouldn't you just be focusing on your chart, surely egos aren't so big as to be trying to convince random strangers on a webforum that you have been nailing trades...surely??
If a thread combined my transparency with some people's claimed talents, we'd have a winner on here. I'm not suggesting people have live screenplays, that's not necessary to do, even I found it distracting. A simple "l 10244, sl 15" within 30 seconds of the trade, then your out result within 30 seconds of getting out, is plenty. But to be beneficial, a retrospective reason as to why a trade was taken would be good. Projection charts are good as well and some people do that, but their live calls make me do this:
Has nobody stepped up to being truly transparent?
1) "l 10233, sl 15" "out +20"
2) "im long"
3) (5 minutes after a move happened) "scalps taken from res. nailed it."
???
I appreciate some people never explicitly said they are making their threads to place live calls and are under no obligation, but some people pretend to be making live calls.
Hi I'm Troy Mclure, you might remember me from this thread that I made for transparency, that I haven't updated for months now since starting up my new business enterprise. That thread was about as open as live calls could ever be and yes, I showed my losses (I was a noob trader, still am).
I've recently come back to this forum and dipped back in to a bit of trading the past 2 weeks but I see there is still a lot of smoke and mirrors on T2W.
What I don't understand is why waste your own time let alone everybody elses? If you're not making live calls properly, shouldn't you just be focusing on your chart, surely egos aren't so big as to be trying to convince random strangers on a webforum that you have been nailing trades...surely??
If a thread combined my transparency with some people's claimed talents, we'd have a winner on here. I'm not suggesting people have live screenplays, that's not necessary to do, even I found it distracting. A simple "l 10244, sl 15" within 30 seconds of the trade, then your out result within 30 seconds of getting out, is plenty. But to be beneficial, a retrospective reason as to why a trade was taken would be good. Projection charts are good as well and some people do that, but their live calls make me do this:
Has nobody stepped up to being truly transparent?
Last edited: