Hi Stirf,
"Reading between the lines, my impression...". I don't know how well you read between the lines, but your impression is wrong. As mentioned you can take a look at my website for hard proof that what Rockwell Trading sells/preaches will lead to nowhere but misery and failure and that includes the book..
If my impression is wrong, then I assume you
have read the book? In which case, I return to my earlier request for some evidence of this by way of an example or two of things in the book that will mislead its readers. You're making alegations here on T2W, therefore, you need to back them up here, and not just redirect people to your website.
The thing is Tim, that forums like trade2win need vendors (I wont use the word scammers) like rockwell and e.g. tradethemarkets to keep the forum going. Your family has to eat as well don't they Tim? So on the one hand T2W is providing a service to traders (experienced or not) so they can exchange thoughts and opinions. It is that part that I appreciate a lot! But on the other hand T2W is giving those same vendors a platform to sell their useless stuff to newbies and those who go from one vendor to another and wonder why nothing works. Being it by payed advertising on the site, through email or having charlatans posting all sorts of good reviews. That sounds to me like a conflict of interest....
T2W needs paid advertising to keep going, otherwise all the useful information that's available for free wouldn't be (available for free - or otherwise). That includes the 'information' you post about Rockwell. On the one hand, you're happy to use T2W to wage your campaign against Rockwell (on numerous forums over a prolonged period of time) while, on the other hand, criticise us for generating an income from advertising. You can't have it both ways I'm afraid! Besides, while I accept that T2W has made mistakes in the past, there is now a procedure in place to ensure that we don't accept advertising from any company whose reputation and credibility has been seriously brouught into question.
In all my years of trading I haven't seen one, no NOT ONE educator that actually has his live trades on record (approved by an accountant) to proof his success. And neither was I able to read anything about it in the thousands of emails I got in reaction to my website and youtube vdo. What better way of marketing is there? "This is what I can teach you and here are the results of that". Those who can, trade and those who can't teach (and sell stuff)..
You're entitled to your view - and it's a popular one. However, it's not the
only one. There are other views on this contentious subject and T2W wouldn't be acting in the best interests of its members if it adopted any one side in preference to any other. My personal view (i.e.
not T2W's view) has always been that the 'those who can, trade and those who can't teach (and sell stuff)' mantra is rubbish.
It is always hard to "read" the intonation or tone in a message like this. Let me just state that I mean well. Though there are disadavantages, I appreciate the service T2W offers and your attention to what traders ask or write. Keep up the good work Tim!
Now, market in the US is about to open so let me get back to what it is all about: trading! I'm out.
P.s. I'm not a native English speaker so sorry if I used the wrong words.
I agree with you that it's very difficult to read the intonation or tone of a post. Very true. And, FWIW, I accept that you mean well and I don't doubt that you believe passionately in everything you say about Rockwell. All I'm saying is that if you want me to believe it too (and I'm open minded on the issue) then you need to back up your claims with specific examples. Otherwise, you just come across as someone who has failed at trading and is looking for someone to else blame - anyone other than the person starring back at you in the mirror.
Tim.